Independent appraisers for Texas policyholders · Certified appraiser & umpire · Statewide Texas Call (832) 503-5866Text (832) 503-5866

Inside the process

What Happens at an Appraisal Inspection, and How the Award Gets Decided

Most homeowners have never watched two estimators argue over a roof. Here is what the appraisal inspection, the appraiser conference and the umpire stage actually look like, and what you need to do at each one.

Before anyone arrives

Once both appraisers are named, they contact each other, exchange the estimates already on file and schedule the inspection. Your appraiser will ask you for access to every damaged area, including the attic and any storage where damaged contents are kept, and will ask you not to begin permanent repairs to disputed items until the inspection is complete. Emergency mitigation (tarping, drying, board-up) should continue; document it.

The inspection

Inspections may be joint, with both appraisers present, or separate. At a roof appraisal expect ladders, chalk, test squares marked on each slope, photographs of every hail hit and soft-metal indicator, and a brittleness test where repairability is in question. At a water or fire appraisal expect moisture meters, measurements of every affected room, photographs of materials and finishes, and a review of your contents list.

You do not need to argue your case during the inspection. Your appraiser is doing that with evidence. Be available to answer factual questions: when the damage was discovered, what repairs have been made, what the room looked like before.

The appraiser conference

After the inspection the two appraisers compare estimates line by line. They are usually written in the same software, so the comparison is concrete: a quantity, a unit price or an included item is either the same or different. The appraisers agree where they can and list the disputed items. On many claims a large share of the gap closes here, because the carrier's appraiser has far more latitude than the field adjuster who wrote the original estimate.

Selecting the umpire

If differences remain, the appraisers jointly select an umpire. Under the 2027 Texas residential rules that happens within 15 days, the umpire must meet the same competence, independence and qualification requirements as the appraisers, and if the appraisers cannot agree on a person, either party may ask the county or district court where the property is located to appoint one, after 10 days' written notice. Umpire fees are typically split equally.

The umpire's review and the award

Each appraiser submits a written statement of the disputed items and the reasons for their position. The umpire may inspect the property, usually with both appraisers present, and then decides each disputed item. An award is written as an itemized amount of loss, typically stated at replacement cost and actual cash value, and signed by the umpire and whichever appraiser agrees. Two signatures make it binding as to the amount of loss. Under the 2027 rules an umpire award must issue within 240 days of the demand.

After the award

The carrier pays the award less the deductible, prior payments and any recoverable depreciation withheld under the policy's replacement-cost terms, which is released when repairs are completed. The award resolves the amount of loss, including causation disputes the panel decided; pure policy-interpretation questions, if any, remain for the carrier and, if necessary, an attorney.

What you should do during the process

Keep mitigating damage and keep receipts. Do not sign a release or accept a "final" payment without reading what it releases. Keep paying premiums. Forward every carrier letter to your appraiser the day it arrives. Deadlines under the new rules run from the demand date, and a late carrier letter can matter.

Joseph Dittman, appraiser and licensed Texas public adjuster

Joseph DittmanCertified insurance appraiser and umpire, licensed Texas adjuster. Full bio

Get started

Apply this to your claim.

Free appraisal review

Tell us where the claim stands. We reply within one business day with a straight answer on whether appraisal fits.

No upfront fee for the review. If we take the engagement, the fee is quoted in writing first. Prefer to talk? Call or text (832) 503-5866.

Disagree with the carrier's number?

Send us the estimate. We will tell you within one business day whether appraisal fits and what it would cost.

Call (832) 503-5866