The roof arguments that end up in appraisal
- Repair versus replacement. The carrier approves a slope or a handful of shingles; the policyholder's estimate replaces the roof.
- Brittleness and repairability. Older three-tab and some laminated shingles cannot be lifted to replace individual tabs without breaking the surrounding shingles. Documenting a brittleness test is a core part of our inspection.
- Matching. Discontinued shingles or siding, and whether a reasonable match is available.
- Code upgrades. Drip edge, ice-and-water shield, decking replacement, ventilation and other items required by the local jurisdiction, where the policy includes ordinance-or-law coverage.
- Collateral damage. Gutters, window screens, HVAC fins, fences, painted surfaces and soft metals that corroborate the hail event and belong in the scope.
- Interior water damage that followed the roof damage.
How we build a roof appraisal position
We walk every slope and photograph test squares, soft metals and collateral indicators. We document shingle type, age, layers and condition, and we perform and record a brittleness test where repairability is in question. Then we price the scope in industry-standard estimating software so the carrier's appraiser and the umpire can compare our estimate against theirs item by item.
The result is not an inflated number. It is a complete, defensible one. Appraisal awards are decided by the two of three signatures, and umpires sign the estimate that holds up, not the biggest one.
Carriers routinely deny roof slopes as wear, mechanical damage or a prior storm. In Texas that is a causation question, and causation is appraisable: the Texas Supreme Court held in State Farm Lloyds v. Johnson (2009) that an appraisal panel deciding the amount of loss may decide which damage the covered hail or wind event caused and which did not. You do not need the carrier's agreement that the storm damaged the roof before you invoke appraisal. The panel sorts it out with test squares, shingle samples and brittleness testing, and awards the covered portion.
Timing matters
Under the 2027 Texas residential appraisal rules, each side has 20 days after a written demand to name its appraiser, the appraisers have 120 days from the demand to try to agree, and any umpire award must issue within 240 days. Those deadlines reward policyholders who arrive with their documentation ready. Call us when the carrier's estimate arrives, not when the deadline does.